These fuckers rate pink lady a 90 but give granny smith a 57 and lemonade apples a 63? Lost their fucking minds; pink lady are just decent and are only saved by their price point. Can't even compete with modern hit-or-miss honeycrisp. No way in fuck are they the third-best apple variety.
Yeah, no shit lemonade apples don't taste like you're drinking lemonade. That's a problem for like the first one you eat if you're really susceptible to marketing, after which you can just enjoy them for what they are: a solidly above-average apple with a unique background lemony flavor that are fun to mix in with other apples.
The granny smith, meanwhile, is a fantastic pie apple and a great sour apple, and most of the review is spent whining endlessly about slightly thick flesh (literally good for you, arguably one of an apple's few advantages health-wise over other fruits).
What the fuck kind of pink ladies have you been eating (ooh err matron etc.)? They should be pretty tart, not the tartest apple in the world but 3.5/5 seems fair to me.
What the fuck kind of pink ladies have you been eating
Ones that are very slightly tart, and given the tight licensure, I'm not willing to grant shitty quality control like I do for honeycrisp for why they don't live up to this alleged true potential.
If an apple makes it to the store shelf, it's a good apple. I eat whichever one is cheapest. At the moment where I shop, that's Gala. But, I also eat Red delicious and Granny Smith. I'm not paying two or three times as much for an apple that's different. Different isn't better, it's just different. Higher price doesn't mean better product, just better marketing, and maybe "new!", which is just different again.
The fact that rankings of food are so contested and almost no one agrees, is proof positive that I'm right, here. One isn't better than the other, just different. No one is wrong for liking what they like. Judging another's taste harshly, especially in food is silly and wrong. But, also in music, and clothing, and any other aesthetic appeal.
(I know I can't say "an apple is an apple and all apples are good" because of how apples are cultivated. But, if a variety has passed the taste test with growers to the point that they get produced in mass quantities, then it's a good apple.)
The most disappointing apple I’ve ever had was an Arkansas black (or might’ve been Alabama black). Cosmetically it’s a gorgeous apple. Nice and round and a deep shade a red, like what you’d expect to see used as a prop in a Snow White production. But when you bite into it it’s a sandy, mealy disgrace.
Eating pigeon pie and squirrel isn't about the food. Especially squirrel, fuck those shit's. They did a few hundred in damages to my mango trees. Why am I upset? because the shit's would knock em off the tree, take a couple bites and leave them for me to clean up. I wouldn't care if they ate it all. They really are pests.
So maybe the apple pie, was the cherry on top of eating the squirrel. Not for the taste, but for the spite.
I love the apple rankings site but remain ever a Honeycrisp ho. I never liked apples until one day I was pregnant and hungry and at Target they had out samples of apple - out of desperation I grabbed one and holy crap, it was everything an apple should be, nothing like anything I'd had before, and I worked at a natural foods store, we got the pink lady and cripps and gala, it's not like I had not tried to like apples.
It will ever be the Honeycrisp, the platonic ideal. Perfectly sweet, perfectly tart, and can be cooked in pies and taste good. I don't need any other apple. My coworker prefers the Cosmic Crisp but I don't.
I don't know how widely available it is outside of Minnesota (Honeycrisp was invented here) but there's a Honeycrisp hard cider called Loon Juice, it's pretty good. I also saw a jug of non alcoholic cider made from them at the grocery store a few days ago.
Oh yay, I get to address my two favorite common misconceptions about the colonial US at once.
There is an element of truth in the assertion that Ben Franklin owned slaves, but it's mostly untrue. He participated in what he was taught to do from an early age, but seeing the effects of slavery first hand changed his mind. He spent the rest of his life as one of that era's most outspoken critics against slavery, even purchasing a printing press to print anti-slavery brochures and pamphlets.
George Washington's wooden teeth are a myth. Wood teeth certainly existed, but were extremely uncommon and only used by people who had nothing else. Most commonly, dentures of that era were made from ivory, animal teeth, or cadaver teeth.
What a joke of a site they don't even have a ranking for my favorite apple. Liberty (NY 55140-19) are great eating apples. The only problem with them: they're only in season once a year.
They don't have a ranking for my favorite apple either. Liberty (NY 55140-19) are great eating apples. The only problem with them: they're only in season once a year.
TheTechnician27
in reply to Varesti • • •These fuckers rate pink lady a 90 but give granny smith a 57 and lemonade apples a 63? Lost their fucking minds; pink lady are just decent and are only saved by their price point. Can't even compete with modern hit-or-miss honeycrisp. No way in fuck are they the third-best apple variety.
Yeah, no shit lemonade apples don't taste like you're drinking lemonade. That's a problem for like the first one you eat if you're really susceptible to marketing, after which you can just enjoy them for what they are: a solidly above-average apple with a unique background lemony flavor that are fun to mix in with other apples.
The granny smith, meanwhile, is a fantastic pie apple and a great sour apple, and most of the review is spent whining endlessly about slightly thick flesh (literally good for you, arguably one of an apple's few advantages health-wise over other fruits).
gnutrino
in reply to TheTechnician27 • • •TheTechnician27
in reply to gnutrino • • •Ones that are very slightly tart, and given the tight licensure, I'm not willing to grant shitty quality control like I do for honeycrisp for why they don't live up to this alleged true potential.
Eq0
in reply to TheTechnician27 • • •ElChinchilla
in reply to Eq0 • • •fonix232
in reply to TheTechnician27 • • •I fucking love granny smith. Best apple ever.
Juicy, slightly sour, a touch tart, perfectly refreshing on a hot summer day.
I've always found pink lady to be weird. It's just so flavourless, the flesh consistency is like wet, gravelly sand, and it gets mushy so fast...
CIA_chatbot
in reply to fonix232 • • •undecidedyellow
in reply to fonix232 • • •FrowingFostek
in reply to Varesti • • •tacosanonymous
in reply to FrowingFostek • • •77/100
They had nice things to say about it
FrowingFostek
in reply to tacosanonymous • • •TrackenDaKracken
in reply to Varesti • • •If an apple makes it to the store shelf, it's a good apple. I eat whichever one is cheapest. At the moment where I shop, that's Gala. But, I also eat Red delicious and Granny Smith. I'm not paying two or three times as much for an apple that's different. Different isn't better, it's just different. Higher price doesn't mean better product, just better marketing, and maybe "new!", which is just different again.
The fact that rankings of food are so contested and almost no one agrees, is proof positive that I'm right, here. One isn't better than the other, just different. No one is wrong for liking what they like. Judging another's taste harshly, especially in food is silly and wrong. But, also in music, and clothing, and any other aesthetic appeal.
(I know I can't say "an apple is an apple and all apples are good" because of how apples are cultivated. But, if a variety has passed the taste test with growers to the point that they get produced in mass quantities, then it's a good apple.)
peter_arbeitsloser
in reply to TrackenDaKracken • • •No.
Leeks
in reply to TrackenDaKracken • • •What if the growers aren’t optimizing for taste, but for the ability to ship them half way across the world and still look presentable?
theedqueen
in reply to Varesti • • •criss_cross
in reply to theedqueen • • •Oddly that’s the apple now ranked as Vomitous Filth
applerankings.com/arkansas-black-apple-review/
Arkansas Black Apple Review - Apple Rankings by The Appleist Brian Frange
theappleist (Apple Rankings by The Appleist Brian Frange)i_need_your_bones
in reply to Varesti • • •Best apple in current meta is the SweeTango but I'm never changing from my of Red Delicious main
applerankings.com/sweetango-apple-review/
SweeTango Apple Review - Apple Rankings by The Appleist Brian Frange
theappleist (Apple Rankings by The Appleist Brian Frange)tempest
in reply to i_need_your_bones • • •tea_n_typewriters
in reply to tempest • • •Skanky
in reply to Varesti • • •myyass
in reply to Varesti • • •Eating pigeon pie and squirrel isn't about the food. Especially squirrel, fuck those shit's. They did a few hundred in damages to my mango trees. Why am I upset? because the shit's would knock em off the tree, take a couple bites and leave them for me to clean up. I wouldn't care if they ate it all. They really are pests.
So maybe the apple pie, was the cherry on top of eating the squirrel. Not for the taste, but for the spite.
tigermountain
in reply to Varesti • • •RBWells
in reply to Varesti • • •I love the apple rankings site but remain ever a Honeycrisp ho. I never liked apples until one day I was pregnant and hungry and at Target they had out samples of apple - out of desperation I grabbed one and holy crap, it was everything an apple should be, nothing like anything I'd had before, and I worked at a natural foods store, we got the pink lady and cripps and gala, it's not like I had not tried to like apples.
It will ever be the Honeycrisp, the platonic ideal. Perfectly sweet, perfectly tart, and can be cooked in pies and taste good. I don't need any other apple. My coworker prefers the Cosmic Crisp but I don't.
AlligatorBlizzard
in reply to RBWells • • •RBWells
in reply to AlligatorBlizzard • • •Carlos Solís
in reply to Varesti • •TheWilliamist
in reply to Varesti • • •Chuck Wendig: Terribleminds – Apple-Obsessed Author Fella
terribleminds.comgastroglizzy
in reply to Varesti • • •Oh yay, I get to address my two favorite common misconceptions about the colonial US at once.
There is an element of truth in the assertion that Ben Franklin owned slaves, but it's mostly untrue. He participated in what he was taught to do from an early age, but seeing the effects of slavery first hand changed his mind. He spent the rest of his life as one of that era's most outspoken critics against slavery, even purchasing a printing press to print anti-slavery brochures and pamphlets.
benjaminfranklinhouse.org/education/benjamin-franklin-and-slavery/
George Washington's wooden teeth are a myth. Wood teeth certainly existed, but were extremely uncommon and only used by people who had nothing else. Most commonly, dentures of that era were made from ivory, animal teeth, or cadaver teeth.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Washington%27s_teeth
George Washington's teeth - Wikipedia
Contributors to Wikimedia projects (Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.)Nalivai
in reply to gastroglizzy • • •HugeNerd
in reply to Varesti • • •qarbone
in reply to HugeNerd • • •confusedbytheBasics
in reply to Varesti • • •unexposedhazard
in reply to Varesti • • •confusedbytheBasics
in reply to unexposedhazard • • •