The media in this post is not displayed to visitors. To view it, please go to the original post.

Earlier this week I unsubscribed from #1Password and moved to #Bitwarden... due to their donation of 300k to DHH's #Omarchy.

I made sure to let them know about the reason, so that hopefully the company would notice those kind of decisions have an impact.

Day one I got messages from their AI system.

But today I got a response by a real human at 1Password (or so it appears).

If you are curious about the company's official response to the backlash, check out the screenshot (and/or #AltText)

reshared this

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

Esther Payne reshared this.

in reply to Lorenzo Millucci

@lmillucci Yes, this is how crisis PR works and it is not a bad thing.
Expecting a handcrafted letter from customer support is main character syndrom.

On the plus side: This letter exists, so there were some teams involved and it is itself a sign that they are reacting.
For whatever consequence...
@_elena

in reply to Leeloo
@leeloo I understood that because they were just "supporting developer and open-source communities" they conveniently "ignored" the implications of funding a project that has clear political position. They think they can fund "just" hosting infrastructure without also helping the people behind the project push their own agendas, and that is what I ment with the usual "don't mix politics with <X>" B.S.
(Sorry, English is not my native language)
in reply to fiend4coffee

@fiend4coffee Proton Pass is very good. I went there from Bitwarden to get EU software instead of US software.
And now KeepassXC, to have full control over where my password files are. It takes some time to figure it out but I like it.

The browser extension for Proton Pass is superior to the Bitwarden one in my not so humble opinion.

@_elena

in reply to Paul - Antifa. LGBTQ+ safe.
@paulk @fiend4coffee I have a Proton plan but I'm afraid of putting all my eggs in one basket. because if someone manages to hack into my Proton account, they would have passwords to my entire digital life. So I prefer to keep things separate ๐Ÿ˜…
in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

Exactly. That's why I moved out too.
>dir
Volume in drive C is Windows

Directory of C:\Users\paul\Nextcloud\Overal

03/09/2026 09:22 <DIR> .
01/09/2026 09:16 <DIR> MaiVolt
03/09/2026 07:56 99.157 Passwords.kdbx
1 File(s) 99.157 bytes

(Yes, sorry, windows. Work laptop)

I know exactly where my passwords are.

@fiend4coffee

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

@paulk @fiend4coffee I recently moved from 1P to Proton Pass but here on fedi someone shared that Proton is equally associated with far right politics. :( So now Iโ€™m back to my quest for self-hosted, family-sharing capable password manager. (People love Keepass but itโ€™s not set up for proper sharingโ€ฆ better for single user.)

I did all this research a few months ago into all the password managers and who was behind them and their featuresโ€ฆ I should write it down somewhere now that everyone is once again shopping around. ๐Ÿ˜…

in reply to fiend4coffee

@fiend4coffee @paulk This is the Proton news for reference:

reddit.com/r/degoogle/comments/1tzbizh/proton_is_funding_the_french_far_right_on_youtube/

I was almost in on Bitwarden but as I recall they use AWS on the backend (so does 1P) and I am also trying to extricate from AWS services (not realistic, I know). I explored self-hosting Bitwarden/Vaultwarden but then you are reliant on Bitwarden the company to keep producing a good client (which youโ€™re using for free). Just as I was testing it, this happened:

fastcompany.com/91542655/bitwarden-scrubs-always-free-and-inclusion-values-from-its-website-as-longtโ€ฆ

And that shadiness turned me off.

Right now I like the looks of @aliasvault and @passbolt, both of which can be self-hosted. Iโ€™m waiting for each to mature a bit as they donโ€™t quite have all the features I need personally.

The good news is there are more options in this space than a year ago! Itโ€™s not just 1P and LastPass and Bitwarden. ๐Ÿ˜

in reply to fiend4coffee

@fiend4coffee @paulk I've been a very happy Bitwarden user for nearly a decade. I switched over after LastPass was bought by LogMeIn.

I use `rbw` on the commandline. github.com/doy/rbw

in reply to Jason Bowen ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ฆ

@jbowen I can believe that. It's a laugh compared to the prices 1Password asks, for instance, and Bitwarden isn't tied to bad people like 1PW is.
Unfortunately my employer is 1PW-addicted.

@fiend4coffee @_elena

in reply to fiend4coffee

@fiend4coffee @paulk Which one? It tends to be very subjective, you might like another.

For example, personally, I don't like KeePassXC, but I like KeePass 2. For others, it's the opposite, and non-XC KeePass 1 plus other third-party implementations are available for download, too. I think it's a massive plus of the KeePasses that I'm not tied to one program using its own file format that nothing else uses, and especially not a mothership in The Cloudยฎ that holds my passwords hostage.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

To me, that reads as โ€œwe didnโ€™t expect backlash from this and donโ€™t yet know what weโ€™ll do about it in the futureโ€, which means: 1- telling them why worked (they know thereโ€™s backlash), and 2- if more people tell them why theyโ€™ll probably have to figure out whether or how to change things (which requires various people to listen to customer support as an org, etc, which is hard).

Which is (and i say this positively, not nihilistically) the best kind of response i would expect from a company of that size.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

Ok, but they don't see that one follows not from the other? Supporting open source projects does not automatically imply supporting a specific dotfile collection's money-laundry. For example they could just give the money to Arch directly.

Come to think of it, a way to save face would be to sever ties with Omarchy and give double the amount to Arch.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

Iโ€™d been with 1Password since 2008, I think โ€” their first iPhone app, maybe? Moved away from it to Apple Passwords last year. Couldnโ€™t justify their increasingly expensive annual fee when theyโ€™d clearly pivoted away from individuals & small businesses towards large, corporate clients.

Iโ€™m lucky to have no Android or Windows devices, so this was easy for me. I donโ€™t envy people now faced with choosing a new password manager.

Seeing โ€œMackayโ€ โ€” with the same, relatively uncommon capitalization I use โ€” at the bottom of the response you got from 1Password only made me sad.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

Someone whom I'm rudely not crediting (sorry, I forgot your username!) put it best:

> We recognize that the NSDAP is closely associated with its founder, and that raises questions about what our support means. Our contribution is made to the NSDAP, not to an individual, and is not an endorsement of any individual's personal or political views.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

good I guess that you got a human response, but sadly, a corporate word salad so not valuable (imo).

You did better than I did when leaving Mullvad - I explicitly said it was because of their co-founders continued patronage of the far right party in Sweden and said I'd be pleased to return once he had no financial interest in the business.

Annoyed af because Proton is nowhere near as good as Mullvad, but cannot support fash.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

#Boycott1Password

#BoycottOmarchy

mastodon.social/@awkapuma/117207356572123170


#Boycott1Password

#BoycottOmarchy

People must not fund, support or interact with fascist, racist, white supremacist rich people who own tech companies.

If companies dont reject a fascist path, we must reject them.

Its in our hands the power to stop them and built a better world with respect and empathy. Hate and violence are not the way.

#Omarchy #1Password
#BoycottOmarchy #BoycottOmarchy


in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ
The media in this post is not displayed to visitors. To view it, please go to the original post.

Leaked Slack comment from the CEO indicates what they really think: "the Nazis are the victims" -- see theverge.com/tech/988536/1password-dhh-linux-controversy

Oblomov reshared this.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ

That sounds like a pile of bullshit to me. If they had done 5 minutes of Googling, they would have known exactly how their support of Omacom would be perceived by large parts of the developer and open-source communities.

People don't usually tend to throw heaps of money at random foundations with no research about who they are and what they're in the news for. At this point, one has to assume that anyone who chooses to support Omarchy does it because of DHH's views, not despite them.

in reply to Elena Rossini ๐ŸŒˆ
It should be clear enough by now that for-profit companies are fascism adjacent, if not full on collaborators. Especially in tech, the brain worms have burrowed deep in that industry. We need some nonprofit or cooperative cloud services that exist and run for the users and not just to inflate the ego of some empty suit.